Roy Gosnell
3/9/14
3/9/14
Earth Science
Even
Mrs. McClellan
Mrs. McClellan
Current Event
Citation:
Webster, Guy, and Jason Maderer. "NASA Mars Orbiters
See Clues to Possible Water Flows." Jpl.nasa.gov. NASA Jet
Propulsion Laboratory, 10 Feb. 1014. Web. 09 Mar. 2014.
<http://www.jpl.nasa.gov/news/news.php?release=2014-042>.
NASA Mars Orbiters See Clues to Possible Water
Flows
The question of whether or not water
exists on Mars today is being studied worldwide. This article is one of many to
give insight on Mars, and if water could exist there in particular.
Furthermore, one NASA’s many spacecrafts and rovers returned and gave needed
information about this topic. The information that was collected by this
specific spacecraft should be able to helps researchers get a better
understanding of Mars’ crust, and if, depending on temperature, water could
flow on the surface. Pictures from Mars show dark, finger-like markings that
fall down Martian slopes when the temperature rises. Scientists have come to
call these streaks “recurring slope lineae,” or RSL, and depending on the
season, they could be result of water. Lujendra Ojha, a graduate student from
the Georgia Institute of Technology was one of the first people to discover
these RSL through images from the High Resolution Imaging Science Experiment
(HiRISE) camera on NASA’s Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter. Ojha states that, “We
still don’t have a smoking gun for existence of water in RSL, although we’re
not sure how this process would take place without water.” These RSL features
found on Mars seem to be somewhat similar to the erosion found by water on
Earth itself. In attempt to try and find if the RSL really are created by
water, or if not by what, Ojha and James Wray, Georgia Tech assistant
professor, looked to find more sites by using the same orbiter’s Compact
Reconnaissance Imaging Spectrometer for Mars instrument. They knew that if it
water created the RSL, a change in minerals would most likely have to be
present. They also searched for minerals that could leave residue in their
wake. They did find sites where some minerals were more vast than others, such
as some iron minerals of several different sizes. However they did not find any
specific connection between the water and minerals. To be able to truly find a
connection between the water and the RSL, an almost perfect temperature should
be available. Ojha said that the RSL are “stronger when it’s warmer,” but also,
“less significant when it’s colder.” There are many explanations for the
changes in sizes, but still there is no definitive answer. The two researchers
continued to look for ideal RSL formation sites that could provide answers. Out
of the 200 possible places, only about 13 were useful. In previous years, NASA
used the rovers Spirit and Opportunity to evaluate Mars, and due to the recent
findings of possible water, many more will likely be tested soon. The search
for water on Mars will likely never stop, and as long as there are pieces of
hope like RSL for people like Wray and Ojha, the Red Planet will continue to be
studied.
Studies
have shown that Mars did have flowing water several billion years ago, but in
our world today, it is not known for sure. Mars is not the only planet that is
being questioned for possible water, for NASA has recently discovered hundreds
of new planets, some of which could be habitable. However, people are most interesting in
discovering whether or not Mars contains flowing water, because of its location
compared to Earth. If free water is eventually found on Mars, that would
absolutely be known as one of the most incredible discoveries ever made, and
would also make people realize that it could be possible for life somewhere
else in space. There are many aspects that are needed for life on a planet, but
water is absolutely the most important. If it is true that RSL does originate
from flowing water, then it is very likely that there will be other planets
somewhere deep in space that could also have water. Any numerous results could
come from the presence of water, but the most important would be the
possibility of another life form in space. The question of whether water is
present leads to another even more difficult question to answer. Are we alone?
I
believe that the authors did a great job in providing specific details about
when and how the information on Mars was discovered, and I also think it was
easy to follow along with what Lujendra Ojha and James Wray were doing in attempt
to learn more about the RSL. I also found it interesting to learn that
scientists are able to understand more about a planet by evaluating it through
advanced technology. The idea of possible water on another planet seems dull,
but when you realize that it could eventually lead to another life form, at
least to me, is very interesting. I think that however the argument was
somewhat one sided, because I am sure that there are people and evidence that
could contradict the findings of Ojha and Wray. It is not a perfect world and
not everyone believes in the same thing, so I think it would have been stronger
if there were a discussion or comparison of several different viewpoints. I
would have also liked to see what RSL really look like, and how they impact
Mars’ surface. Additionally, by showing a before and after picture of a
location that had recently been effected by RSL, I think it would have been
very appealing, as it would have allowed for a sense of change and mystery. I
also think that adding a conclusion about why the water is important, and how
it could impact future life, would have made the article better because it
would have made the reader think about how truly important this is, and how it
could impact their lives. Overall I enjoyed reading the article and I am
interested in learning more about how water could eventually result in life on
other planets.
Roy, your current event was very well done. Personally, I am very interested in Mars and our galaxy in general. I even tried to get my parents to let me sign up for Mars One! This article ties a little into my current event. My current event is on ringwoodite, a mineral that contains 1% water. Many scientists believe that there is ringwoodite on Mars, which means there may be water on Mars. However ringwoodite is in meteorites and diamonds and usually these diamonds are buried deep below so it would be hard to recover them, especially on Mars.
ReplyDeleteI think it is very clear that you understood your article and were actually interested in what you were reading about. You went into so much detail and it is very evident that you got a lot out of this current event. You did a very good job of explaining the RSL and how scientists found out about them and what could they mean. I also like your ideas of what this could mean to our society. This invention could potentially make Mars habitable! But this could open up a whole new spectrum. If Mars is found to have water, then there could definitely be water on other planets. This also leads to the question; is there other life out there? We are just one step closer to having all our questions answered.
I don’t really have any suggestions for you; the only thing I would say is maybe cut down your summary paragraph a little bit. There was a lot of information and maybe you could have tried to condense some of it. I hope scientists continue to do research on this subject and find definite answers about these RSL.
Very interesting article Roy. I thought your critiques were spot-on, however the article does indeed link to pictures of the RSL and I even found a video with a series of images taken at different times stitched together to make a movie. You had to click to a few different pages, but I found it through the original article you posted. Here is an example of RSL over time (it takes a while to load the page) http://photojournal.jpl.nasa.gov/archive/PIA14472.gif
ReplyDeleteand here is another: http://photojournal.jpl.nasa.gov/archive/PIA14475.gif
Pretty cool!
I thought your summary was accurate, and I appreciated your level of detail.
The relevancy of water on Mars to society can seem a bit a stretch, but I thought you did a nice job of tying it in to its scientific significance and to the deep question, "Are we alone?"
Another reason liquid water on Mars is relevant, is that it may make the planet easier to terraform and colonize. This science fiction idea is discussed in great detail (with a high amount of scientific accuracy) in the Kim Stanley Robinson series "Red Mars."
Finally, since you and Maria are both interested in Mars, maybe you can't fly to Mars, but I recommend you both volunteer to help interpret images of Mars' surface to learn more about Martian weather. Sign up at "Zooniverse" and check out the Mars mission. No parental permission needed!
https://www.zooniverse.org/
Finally, Roy, why wasn't this submitted on Turnitin??? Really...