Maria Louka 3/14/14
Earth Science C Block Mrs. McClellan
Redfern, Simon. "Mineral
Hints at Bright Blue Rocks Deep in the Earth." BBC News. N.p., 12
Mar. 2014. Web. 18 Mar. 2014.
<http://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-26553115>.
Kimberlites are a
type of volcanic rock, which erupt and then bring up to the Earth’s surface
diamonds. Professor Graham Pearson, from the University of Alberta, was
recently studying a type of diamond that had erupted from a
100-million-year-old kimberlite. This diamond was found in Juina, Brazil, and
is thought to be very rare. Soon after beginning to research this diamond,
Pearson and his team found that the diamond contained ringwoodite. Ringwoodite
is a type of mineral that forms only under 410 to 600 kilometers under the
Earth’s surface. This helped scientists come to the understanding of “how deep”
some diamonds come from (how far down the Earth they are). One very interesting
thing the scientists found about the ringwoodite is that it contains 1% water.
But if this ringwoodite is so far down and it makes up a big part of the “deep
Earth,” that means that the “deep Earth,” is covered in lots of water. The
Earth’s interior is then very wet. Water is present at the lithosphere and goes
through the upper mantle all the way down to where these diamonds are found. A
lot of this ringwoodite is found in a place called the “transition zone,” right
before the lower mantle and under the upper mantle. This is where the
ringwoodite is believed to be and this area is believed to be filled with water
or practically a “huge ocean.” This discovery of the ringwoodite is a very big
step for us because it is the first evidence that water could be stored in the
deep interiors of planets. This has been an ongoing controversy for about 25
years now (whether the deep Earth is wet or dry). Professor Joseph Smyth has
been studying ringwoodite for many years and he says about this discovery that
it “implies that hydrogen may control the interior processes of the Earth just
as it controls the surface processes.” In addition it suggests that there may
be more water planets in our galaxy because ringwoodite is also found in
meteorites. Meteorites are from space so there may be more ringwoodite in space
on various planets (they believe that Mars has ringwoodite).
This ringwoodite
really fascinates me and I think it is so cool how there is so much water deep
in the Earth that we barely even knew about. This idea of whether the deep
interior of the Earth is wet or dry has been an idea of debate for many years
now. But finally the idea of the debate has been solved. This helps show us
that there is lots of water deep down in the “deep Earth,” showing us how much
water there really is on Earth (more than we ever thought) and this could
potentially help solve water problems we have (droughts) one day. This
discovery helps us to come to all new conclusions about science and what the
“center of the earth” might really look like. Earth is primarily considered a
water planet because the Earth’s surface is made up of 70% water. Ringwoodite in
many cases is found in meteorites. This shows us that there may be many more
“water planets,” in our galaxy. Meteorites originate in space. If ringwoodite
is all over space that means that water is all over space. This is one step to
us learning about if planets are habitable and if one-day humans could live on
them or if there are any living creatures on these planets. If there is
ringwoodite on planets that means that there is water on these planets (most
likely). Scientists think that there may have been plate tectonics on various
planets that caused this ringwoodite to go deep into the interior of these
planets. If the ringwoodite was so far down into our Earth because of plate
tectonics that forced it to go so deep, then there may be lots of ringwoodite
on other planets that is just concealed as of now. It took a long time for them
to recover this ringwoodite from the diamonds in Earth, so it will most likely
take astronomers and various scientists a long time to discover the diamonds on
another planet in our galaxy. Scientists believe that there is ringwoodite on
Mars as well.
I think this article
was well written, but there are a few criticisms I would have to make. First
off, the author talks about how ringwoodite contains water and this suggests
that there may be water all over space, but does not elaborate much on this. I
viewed other articles on this ringwoodite and they elaborate more on the galaxy
side of ringwoodite and what it could mean. If the ringwoodite is in various
planets it could be a huge discovery for science. The main point about the
article is how these minerals are deep in the Earth, but I think a little
elaboration on the planet portion would have been better. In addition, the
article doesn’t elaborate much on how this water could help our Earth. It talks
about how it is deep down and it has a lot of water in it, but how could this
help Earth and humans in the future? Another thing I would have liked the
article to talk more about is what they are doing to try and recover more
ringwoodite and what technologies they are working on to try and dig deeper
into the Earth. This ringwoodite and its water could seriously help the world
and imagine what else might be down there that could help us too.
You did a good job explaining what everything was for the most part. The only thing I was confused on why there was ringwoodite in outer space if it ‘forms only under 410 to 600 kilometers under the Earth’s surface’. Did the ringwoodite get propelled into space? I would understand if this part was not elaborated upon due to the fact that the article possibly did not explain it because you seem to think so as well. I also believe that ringwoodite is an interesting substance that can become useful to us in the future. Although, I was also wondering what was meant when you said that there was water in the rock. Does that mean that if I break it will water drip out? If so, that could be very useful, as you said. It could be an extra supply of clean water that is difficult to pollute.
ReplyDeleteI find it interesting that there might be ringwoodite on Mars. That means that there is even more water than we thought on Mars and greater potential for life on the planet. I also learned that kimberlite gives us diamonds. I did not understand what erupted though. Was it the kimberlite, or did the volcanoes erupt the kimberlite?
This review could be better if you did not bring up the fact that they did not include information on how this rock was found in space. I feel like the article was focusing on the fact that the discovery of this rock deep in Earth meant that there was more water on our planet than previously thought. I do not think the article wanted to go so much into the fact that there was ringwoodite in outer space and water out there. That seems to have been brought up many times before and you found lots of articles to prove it. Otherwise, I think you did a fantastic job summarizing this article and I was very happy to learn about it.
I thought your review of this very interesting current was very detailed and had a good flow to it. I think you explained mostly everything right making sure that the reader knew what everything was. you did a good job defining some of the elements, which I thought made this review easier to read. I never knew that one rock can help scientists determine how much water there is on our planet earth. it was also new to me, that mars might have a ringwoodite, which can possible mean that there is more water on planet mars than wee had thought there were. its also interesting how ringwoodite is found in meteorites shows us that there may be more “water planets,” in our galaxy.
ReplyDeleteEmma raises a lot of thoughtful questions. Maria, maybe for your next "comment" you could respond to some of Emma's questions?
ReplyDelete