Lain Miller
Current Events March 25th
Rao, Joe. "'Comets of the Centuries': 500 Years of the
Greatest Comets Ever Seen." Space.com. Skywatching Columnist, 23 Dec. 2013. Web. 23 Mar. 2014.
I
chose to read the article “Comets of the Centuries: 500 Years of the Greatest
Comets Ever Seen” by Joe Roa because I found an interest to research and
investigate comets more, when we learned about them in lab. So I thought a
great way to do this would be to learn about some of the most famous comets yet
to be recorded. This article provides a list of the most famous comets from the
sixteenth to the twentieth century. First is, The Great Comet of 1577, which
appeared on November 1st in Peru and was sighted across the world
until it finally dropped out of the view of the naked eye on January 26th
1578. It was 16.7 million miles from the sun at its perihelion (or closest
point to the surface of the sun) on October 27th and took 5 days to
be sighted. The next comet is, The Great Comet of 1680, discovered by the
German astronomer, Gottfried Kirch, making him the first astronomer to discover
a comet with a telescope, on November 14th 1680. At its perihelion
on December 18th it was 128 thousand miles from the sun’s surface.
At its greatest magnitude, the tail measured 90 degrees. It was visible until
February 1681. The Great Comet of 1744 is known to be sighted by Philippe Loys
De Chesaux on November 29th 1743 and remained visible past March of
1744. At it’s most the magnitude of the comet was -7 on February 27th.
At its perihelion on March 1st it measured 20.5 million miles from
the sun. At one point, in March, it was sighted to have 6 tails. Both Comets of
1680 and 1744 were noted to be equivalent to Venus in brightness and visibility,
while the comet of 1744 rivaled Sirius, the brightest star in the sky. The
Great September Comet of 1822 first spotted on September 1st by a
group of Italian sailors and was visible in daylight from September fourteenth to
late December. At its Perihelion on December 17th it measured 275
thousand miles from the sun. The comets is referred to as a “Super Comet” and
perhaps one of the brightest comets ever to be seen, its radiance was described
as scarcely fainter than the limb of the sun, and its magnitude registered
1,000 times brighter than the full moon. In the end it exploded, with it’s
nucleus separating into at least 4 parts. Comet Ikeya-Seki of 1965 was the
greatest comet of the 20th century. At its perihelion on October 21st
it measured 744 thousand miles from the sun. It was described as “10 times
brighter than the full moon” by its Japan-based discoverer. Its magnitude
corresponded to -15 degrees and its nucleus broke into two parts. It was
discovered just before it’s perihelion and dominated the sky until late
November. Both the comets of 1965 and 1822 were members of the Kreuz Sungrazing
Group of Comets. The greatest comet of the twentieth century would have been
ISON thus far, but it fizzled and turned out to be a dud, but the century is
only 14 years old, so we continue to wait.
Throughout
all of these amazing comets, there are many strong commonalities. Firstly the
discoveries of the comets seem to always come up around October or November.
These Comets stay visible into the sky until only about a month after their
perihelion, making the first half of their journey (in our view) much longer
than the second half. Two of them, the comets of 1680 and 1744 were noted to be
equivalent to Venus in brightness and visibility. And the last two comets, the
comets of 1965 and 1822, were members of the Kreuz Sungrazing Group of Comets.
Meaning that some of the closest comets to the sun were the most modern. And
they were both had their nucleus’ explode. The last two were described as more
bright than the descriptions in the first two, suggesting that comets may be
getting brighter or more powerful, which is something we should look into. Four
out of the five comets were closer to the end of their centuries, which helps
explain why we have yet to see a major comet in the twenty first century. It is
very important for us to take not of the comets we see in the sky so that we
may see the patterns of their orbits. Comets have an olyptical orbit (very
oval/eccentric) where there perihelion (distance closest to the sun) and
aphelion (farthest distance from the sun) are very off balance, which is why we
see some comets twice in a decade and then not again for thousands of years.
Their orbits can range from 200-100000000 years. Their orbits help give us an
idea of the vastness in the solar system. It allowed us to discover that comets
came from other parts of the solar system, which are millions of miles away and
yet to be seen, such as The Oort Cloud and The Kuiper Belt.
I
thought this article was an interesting approach to an article on comets. I
think it is very important to be aware of some of the most famous comets in history,
but I also recognize that they are slightly opinion based and bias toward the
author’s favorites, not an official “most popular” comet. I also realize that
this article is one year old so there may have been more popular comets after
the ISON comet. I believe the author had a good division between the centuries,
but it was written more so in sections than an actually essay format which
makes it look less professional. I liked the author’s consistency in putting
the statistics for their discovery, visibility dates, and their perihelion
distance, but I thought he was inconsistent with the degree of the comet’s
tail, which he mentioned in the first centuries, but should have continued in
the other centuries. I also thought he could have gone on to analyze some of
the commonalities such as the similar times of year they are in the sky and
lack of visibility soon after the perihelion. He also could have given some
background on comets by saying something like; “Sir Edmund Halley first
proposed the idea of comets in 1704 as re-occurring objects in the sky from
leftover debris from the formation of the solar system. They are known as
‘dirty snowballs’ because they are small icy objects with rock”. Overall I
though it was a very unique article and enjoyed the author’s friendly yet
informative and descriptive writing style.
Lain, excellent report!
ReplyDeleteI really liked how you were able to analyze the data yourself a bit and notice some patterns in the comets. One thing to look into, why is it that great comets often appear in the fall?
Your critique was very thoughtful and one of the more thorough ones I have seen in a current event report this year.