John Seminara 5/23/14
Earth Science Current Event #2
Works
Cited:
Vergano, Dan.
"Weird Winter: Is the Pacific to Blame?" National Geographic.
National Geographic Society, 22 May 2014. Web. 23 May 2014. <http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2014/05/140522-climate-global-warming-winter-science/?rptregcta=reg_free_np&rptregcampaign=20131016_rw_membership_r1p_us_se_w>.
Weird Winter: Is the Pacific to Blame?
The
Article that I read, entitled, Weird
Winter: Is the Pacific to Blame, written by Dan Vergano, essentially
discussed the rather peculiar weather that occurred in the Western Hemisphere
this past winter. The main focus of the article was to suggest the idea that
the strange winter was caused by a “curiously warm winter in the western
Pacific.” One of the most interesting notes made by this author would be the
data that suggests Alaska endured a rather warm winter while other places such
as Detroit and England froze. In addition, the author noted that the American
Midwest had one of the coldest winters on record, as a result of the repetitive
polar vortex, as described by meteorologists. A polar vortex is a very cold
low-pressure system that caps the arctic and is normally positioned by the
polar jet stream flowing down over the U.S. This winter, one cause that led to
a continuous pattern of polar vortex’s that developed over the U.S would be the
speedy north-south winds that allowed artic air to flow deep into the U.S.
According to one scientist who works for the science department in the White
House, the warming of the artic and melting of sea ice there caused the change
in the jet stream, which ultimately led to the more rotten winter. On the
contrary, a different scientist proposed that the warming of the western
Pacific Ocean was to blame for the harsher winter conditions. According to the
analysis, abnormally warm Pacific Ocean waters stretched roughly from Fiji to
Indonesia. Subsequently, they were able to form tremendous storms with energy
that reached high into the jet stream and rerouted the jet stream. The loopy
jet stream sent warm air into Alaska and colder air down to freeze the rest of
the continent. Nevertheless, it is clear to most scientists that a winter
similar to our last is not foreseeable anytime in the near future. However, it
is said that during an El Nino warmer winds are pushed into the western Pacific
through trade winds. In addition, the incredible amount of rain across North
America and in the Pacific was also a consequence of the warmer pacific and
also contributed to the altered jet stream across the U.S. Ultimately, this
article discussed some of the unique aspects of this winter and some of the
contributing factors to the harsher conditions across the U.S, demonstrated by some
of the examples including a warmer Pacific Ocean, altered jet stream, and
lastly, some robust climate changes. Yet, most of the information that was
summarized from this article clearly pertains to everyday life. First off, the
articles explanation of why the winter was so harsh leads into some current
environmental issues such as man-made climate change. Because the arctic
climate increased which caused sea ice to melt, there is subsequent speculation
that man-made climate changes amplified some of the effects, potentially even
enough to help alter the jet stream in North America. This obviously
transitions the harsh weather to global warming, however some scientists remain
skeptical that there is any correlation at all. Still, it demonstrates that people
can impact the weather by changing some everyday routines such as walking or
riding a bike rather than driving. Many small changes undertaken by the general
population could possibly lead to a decrease in man-made climate changes and
make winters a little bit more bearable on the people who suffered from the
harsh 2014 winter. Although it is more likely that an abnormally warm Pacific
caused the climate change, people can still be more careful about their
decision making to reduce the amount of climate change that humans contribute
to the environment.
Although
the article exhibited very imperative information as well as how that
information relates to society, the article did still lack some important
content and analysis. I think that it is clear the author used many different
reliable sources and gave informative backgrounds as to where the information
he used is coming from. With this being said, his development of some of the
ideas and statements are rather lackluster, for he could have looked further
into the past and dug out other studies done on relating changes in water
temperatures or climate changes to new weather developments. It is blatant that
one of the more important aspects of the article that the author is lacking is
past examples of climate change and changes in water temperature impacting
weather. In addition, it would have been more interesting than necessary to
look briefly into the weather occurrences in Europe and Asia this past winter,
which would possibly uncover climate changes in different regions on a more
global scale. Lastly, another notable point that this article is lacking would
be that the climate change impacted crop production in the U.S during this past
winter due to very cold temperatures. Nonetheless, the article still did an
excellent job at relaying an enormous amount of significant information while
demonstrating its impact on society.
John, I think this is an exceptional current event. I think you presented all of the facts in a very coherent way, which is important because you want your readers to understand everything you're saying, and if the info is not worded clearly, this understanding won't occur. I also thought it was great how in depth you went about this topic. You explained the article very well, and gave me a really good understanding of why we had such a crazy winter. And I thought your critique paragraph was great too. You had a lot of good feedback, and it was actually relevant. You weren't afraid to voice your opinion, and I loved that.
ReplyDeleteI did not what a polar vortex was, although I had heard that term used countless times this winter to describe the wacky weather. I appreciated how you defined and explained it in your summary, and now I know what it really means. I also did not know that while Northeast and Midwest experienced brutal winters, the West coast and Alaska had rather warmer winters. I would be intrigued to find out if these two events had any correlation, because I was not aware that we weren't the only ones experiencing strange weather.
One thing you could have done better in this current event is make it less wordy. It was clearly full of information, and I could understand it fine. But it was long and often boring for me to read. I just think that you could have written the same summary and critique with fewer words, and the reader wouldn't be bored. Otherwise, this is excellent. Great work John-O